If Human Resources discovers an active employee on the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) Wanted List, the corporation must immediately suspend the worker and consult an employment and immigration law firm. Harbouring an undocumented foreign national carries massive fines under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, but firing them without due process breaches provincial labour laws.
Managing corporate compliance in Canada requires a delicate balance between federal immigration rules and provincial employment standards. A nightmare scenario for any HR department-whether operating a manufacturing plant in Ontario or a tech firm in British Columbia-is discovering that one of your current employees has an outstanding Canada-wide warrant issued by the CBSA. This usually means the employee has evaded a deportation order and is living in Canada illegally.
Ignoring the situation is not an option. 📝 Under Section 124 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), employing a foreign national who is not authorized to work in Canada is a serious federal offence. However, acting too hastily and firing an employee based on a simple web search can trigger a wrongful dismissal lawsuit if it turns out to be a case of mistaken identity. Engaging a corporate law firm is essential to navigate this high-risk crisis smoothly.
Step-by-Step Corporate Response for HR Departments in Canada
When an employee’s name and photograph appear on a CBSA public warrant list, human resources must follow a strict legal protocol. The goal is to protect the company from federal prosecution while respecting the employee’s basic labour rights.
Step 1: Discretely Verify the Employee’s Identity
Do not confront the employee immediately. 🔍 HR must first cross-reference the CBSA wanted poster with the employee’s internal personnel file. Compare the full name, date of birth, photographs, and the Social Insurance Number (SIN) provided at hiring. People can share identical names, and acting on an assumption can lead to a costly human rights or defamation lawsuit.
Step 2: Suspend the Employee Pending Investigation
Once you reasonably suspect a match, you must remove the employee from the workplace to stop the ongoing offence of employing an unauthorized worker. Issue a formal, non-disciplinary administrative suspension. Whether this suspension is with or without pay depends heavily on your specific provincial Employment Standards Act and the employment contract; a law firm must advise you on this step.
Step 3: Demand Proof of Work Authorization
During the suspension, formally request that the employee provide updated proof of their legal right to work in Canada. 📂 Ask for a valid Work Permit, Permanent Resident card, or Canadian passport. Give them a strict, reasonable deadline (e.g., 48 hours) to produce the original documents. If they are actually on the CBSA warrant list, they will not be able to produce valid, unexpired IRCC documents.
Step 4: Contact Corporate Legal Counsel
Simultaneously, HR must engage outside legal counsel specializing in Canadian immigration and labour law. The law firm will advise the corporate directors on their potential liability. They will also guide the company on whether it is legally mandatory to proactively report the employee’s last known address and work schedule to the CBSA, balancing IRPA requirements with PIPEDA (privacy) regulations.
Step 5: Proceed with Formal Termination
If the employee fails to provide valid legal status or admits to being the person on the CBSA warrant list, their employment contract has legally been frustrated. 🚪 The company can now terminate the employee for cause. Because they lack the legal capacity to fulfill the employment contract in Canada, the company is generally not required to provide statutory notice or severance pay.
How Much Does Non-Compliance Cost a Canadian Business?
Failing to take immediate action when you discover an undocumented worker can result in devastating financial and reputational damage. The CBSA actively audits businesses, and ignorance is rarely a successful defence if the information was publicly available. All figures are in Canadian dollars (CAD).
- IRPA Fines (Corporate): Employing an unauthorized foreign national can result in fines up to $50,000 CAD per violation and potential jail time for corporate directors.
- Wrongful Dismissal Claims: If HR fires the wrong person, defending a wrongful dismissal lawsuit can cost a business $10,000 to $30,000 CAD in legal fees, plus massive damages.
- Law Firm Consultation: Retaining an employment law firm to manage the crisis and draft the suspension/termination letters generally costs $400 to $800 CAD per hour.
| Risk Category | Potential Financial Penalty (CAD) | Legal Source |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Immigration Fine | Up to $50,000 per worker | IRPA Section 124 |
| Wrongful Termination Lawsuit | $10,000 – $100,000+ | Provincial Common Law |
| Corporate Legal Consultation | $1,500 – $5,000 (Crisis Mgmt) | Private Law Firm Fees |
How Long Does the HR Process Take?
When dealing with a CBSA warrant, speed is critical. ⏱ The initial verification and administrative suspension should occur within 24 to 48 hours of discovering the wanted list entry. The entire investigation, including the deadline for the employee to present valid immigration documents and the final termination, should be completely wrapped up within 3 to 5 business days.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is the company legally required to call the CBSA to report the employee?
While IRPA penalizes you for employing the person, there is generally no strict statutory duty for a private business to actively call the police or CBSA to turn them in. However, if CBSA investigators contact your HR department, you must cooperate fully and provide employment records; lying to an officer is a criminal offence.
Can we just let the employee work remotely to avoid CBSA raids?
Absolutely not. Harbouring a fugitive or intentionally restructuring their job to help them evade federal immigration enforcement is a severe criminal act. The company and its directors could be charged with conspiracy or harbouring undocumented migrants.
How did the employee get a SIN if they are on a wanted list?
Many individuals on the CBSA list originally entered Canada legally as students or workers and obtained a valid Social Insurance Number. They later overstayed their visas or had their refugee claims denied. HR must check the expiration dates on all SINs starting with a “9”.
Do we have to pay out accrued vacation pay upon termination?
Yes. Even if the employee’s contract is frustrated due to a lack of immigration status, provincial labour laws (like Ontario’s ESA) still require the employer to pay out all wages and accrued vacation pay earned up to the exact moment of suspension/termination.
Leave a Reply