Under Section 11(b) of the Charter (the “Jordan Framework”), your federal criminal charges must generally be tried within 18 months in a provincial court, or 30 months in a superior court. If the Crown delays your trial beyond these limits, your charges could be permanently stayed (dismissed).
The Canadian justice system is built on the principle that justice delayed is justice denied. When you are charged with a federal criminal offence, having a dark cloud hang over your head for years can destroy your career, drain your finances, and cause severe psychological stress. To combat the chronic backlog in Canadian courts, the Supreme Court of Canada established strict timelines in a landmark 2016 case known as R. v. Jordan. This ruling fortified your rights under Section 11(b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Today, the Crown prosecutor and the institutional court system have hard deadlines. Whether your trial is taking place at the Superior Court of Justice in Ontario, the Court of King’s Bench in Alberta, or a provincial court in British Columbia, the state must move efficiently. 📅 If your trial experiences unreasonable delay caused by the Crown or a lack of court resources, a skilled criminal defence lawyer can file an application to have your charges completely stayed-meaning the prosecution ends immediately, and you walk away without a criminal record for that specific offence.
Step-by-Step Process for a Section 11(b) Application in Canada
Filing a Jordan application is a highly technical legal maneuver. It is not an automatic process; your defence lawyer must proactively petition the court and prove the math. Here is how the process generally unfolds.
Step 1: Determine the Applicable Ceiling (18 vs. 30 Months)
The first step is identifying which maximum time limit (ceiling) applies to your case. If you are facing a summary conviction or an indictable offence proceeding entirely in a provincial court (without a preliminary inquiry), the ceiling is 18 months from the date the charge was laid to the anticipated end of the trial. If your case includes a preliminary inquiry or proceeds to a superior court, the ceiling increases to 30 months.
Step 2: Calculate the Total Delay
The clock starts ticking the exact day the police formally swear the Information (lay the charge) against you. ⏱ Your lawyer will calculate the total time elapsed from that start date to the scheduled conclusion of your trial. If this total time is mathematically lower than the 18 or 30-month ceiling, a Section 11(b) application will generally not succeed unless you can prove extraordinary prejudice.
Step 3: Subtract Defence-Caused Delays
The Supreme Court made it clear that accused persons cannot intentionally stall their own trial and then complain about delays. Any delay caused directly by the defence-such as changing lawyers multiple times, requesting unnecessary adjournments, or failing to show up for a court date-is subtracted from the total time. The remaining number is the “Net Delay.”
Step 4: Assess Exceptional Circumstances
If the Net Delay exceeds the Jordan ceiling, the Crown has one last chance to save their case. They must prove that “exceptional circumstances” caused the delay. 📌 This could include unforeseen medical emergencies for key witnesses, highly complex multi-jurisdictional wiretap investigations, or sudden global events. The burden is heavily on the Crown prosecutor to justify the failure to meet the deadline.
Step 5: File the Application and Attend the Hearing
If the math is in your favour, your lawyer will draft and file a formal Notice of Application outlining the Charter violation. A hearing is held before a judge, separate from your main trial. If the judge agrees that the Net Delay exceeds the ceiling without a valid excuse, they will issue a Stay of Proceedings. The trial stops immediately, and you are free to go.
How Much Does a Charter Challenge Cost?
Filing a constitutional challenge requires extensive legal research and courtroom advocacy, making it a significant legal expense.
- Initial Retainer: Hiring a reputable defence lawyer for a serious indictable offence typically starts with a retainer of $5,000 to $10,000 CAD.
- Drafting the Section 11(b) Application: Because the lawyer must review years of court transcripts to calculate exact delay periods, preparing the application can cost an additional $3,000 to $7,000 CAD.
- Hearing Fees: Representing you at the delay hearing adds further hourly fees, pushing total trial costs easily over $15,000 to $25,000 CAD depending on complexity.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The foundation of this process relies on time. You generally cannot file a Jordan application until the case has actually dragged on for close to 18 to 30 months. Once the application is formally filed, the court will usually schedule the Charter hearing a few weeks before your actual trial is set to begin. If the judge grants the stay, the matter is resolved instantly on that day.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does the COVID-19 pandemic still count as an exceptional circumstance?
Historically, yes. Delays directly caused by the original 2020-2021 court shutdowns were considered exceptional. However, as of 2026, the Crown can no longer use the pandemic as a blanket excuse for current mismanagement. Courts expect the system to have adapted by now.
Do I get a criminal record if a stay of proceedings is granted?
No. A stay of proceedings halts the prosecution entirely. Because you were not found guilty, you will not receive a criminal record for that specific charge. However, the record of the arrest itself may still exist in police databases.
Does a Section 11(b) delay apply to minor summary convictions?
Yes. The 18-month ceiling applies to all matters proceeding in a provincial court, including less serious summary conviction offences like minor theft or simple assault.
What happens if my lawyer is the reason for the delay?
If your legal counsel explicitly waives the delay or repeatedly asks for adjournments because they are unprepared or double-booked, that time is deducted from the total delay. You cannot benefit from delays your own defence team created.
Can the Crown appeal a stay of proceedings?
Yes. If the judge grants your Jordan application and stays the charges, the Crown prosecutor has the right to appeal that decision to a higher court, such as the provincial Court of Appeal.
Leave a Reply