If the Parole Board of Canada intends to refuse your application, they will mail you a formal “Proposal to Deny” letter. You generally have 90 days to submit written representations to the Board explaining why you deserve the record suspension and providing strong evidence of your sustained rehabilitation before a final decision is made.
Receiving a letter from the federal government stating they intend to refuse your application can be incredibly stressful and disheartening. However, it is vital to understand that a “Proposal to Deny” is not a final decision. In Canada, the principles of administrative fairness require the Parole Board of Canada (PBC) to give you a fair chance to respond, explain your circumstances, and defend your application before they officially close your file.
A record suspension (formerly known as a pardon) is never granted automatically, especially if you have a complex history involving an indictable offence. 🔍 The Board’s primary mandate is to ensure public safety and confirm that granting the suspension would bring you a measurable benefit. If the Board members feel they do not have enough evidence of your good behaviour, they will pause the process and ask for more information. This is your critical window to act.
Step-by-Step Process in Canada
Whether you reside in Toronto, Vancouver, Calgary, or Halifax, the process of responding to the Parole Board of Canada is exactly the same because this is a strictly federal matter governed by the Criminal Records Act. You will not go to your local provincial courthouse; instead, you will correspond directly with the PBC’s headquarters in Ottawa.
Step 1: Reading the Proposal to Deny Letter
The very first step is to carefully read the letter you received from the PBC. 📝 This document will clearly outline the specific reasons why the Board members are considering refusing your record suspension. Common reasons include recent negative interactions with local police (even if they did not result in a new summary conviction), unpaid court fines, or a poorly written measurable benefit form that failed to demonstrate how you have rehabilitated your life.
Step 2: Gathering Additional Evidence
Once you understand the Board’s concerns, you must gather new evidence to address them directly. If they questioned your lifestyle, you might need to obtain letters of reference from your employer, community leaders, or volunteer organizations. If they noted financial instability, you could provide proof of employment, tax assessments from the CRA, or receipts showing you have finally paid off old court restitution orders.
Step 3: Drafting Written Representations
This is the most critical step. You must write a formal response, known as “written representations,” directly to the Parole Board of Canada. 🖨 This letter must be polite, factual, and strictly focused on addressing the exact concerns raised in their proposal. Many applicants in Canada choose to hire a local law firm at this stage, as a lawyer can help draft a highly persuasive, legally sound argument that clearly demonstrates your sustained rehabilitation.
Step 4: Submitting Your Response on Time
By law, you are usually given exactly 90 days from the date on the proposal letter to submit your written representations. If you miss this deadline, the PBC will proceed to make a final decision based only on the original information they have, which almost always results in a final denial. Ensure you send your package via registered mail so you have a tracking number as proof of delivery.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Responding to a Proposal to Deny does not require you to pay another federal application fee. 💵 However, gathering additional evidence and seeking professional help can incur out-of-pocket costs:
- Parole Board of Canada fee: $0 CAD (There is no fee to submit written representations).
- Obtaining New Documents: Usually $20 to $100 CAD, depending on whether you need new police checks, court printouts, or transcripts.
- Law Firm Fees: If you hire a lawyer to review your denial and draft your response, legal fees typically range from $750 to $2,500 CAD, depending on the complexity of your criminal record.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline for a proposed refusal case is significantly longer than a standard application. ⌛ While a standard summary conviction application takes up to 6 months to process, cases involving a “Proposal to Deny” can take up to 24 months in total. Once the PBC receives your written representations, it may take them several months to review your new evidence and issue their final written decision.
Common Reasons for Denial vs. How to Respond
To give you a better idea of how to handle this situation, here is a breakdown of common PBC concerns and the best ways to address them.
| PBC Concern in the Proposal | Effective Strategy for Written Representations |
|---|---|
| Recent police contact (no charges) | Provide a detailed, honest explanation of the incident showing you were not at fault, backed by a local police report. |
| Unclear measurable benefit | Submit a letter from an employer stating they will promote you if the record is cleared, or proof of enrollment in a college program. |
| Nature of the original offence | Provide certificates from completed anger management, substance abuse, or counselling programs to prove deep rehabilitation. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What happens if my record suspension is officially denied?
If you receive a final denial, your criminal record remains active in the RCMP database. You will not be able to apply for jobs that require a clear record, and you may face issues travelling or dealing with the IRCC. However, you are generally allowed to reapply for a record suspension after a waiting period of one year.
Can I appeal a final decision by the Parole Board of Canada?
There is no traditional “appeal” process within the PBC for a denied record suspension. If you believe the Board made a serious legal or procedural error, your only option is to apply to the Federal Court of Canada for a Judicial Review, which is a highly complex process requiring a lawyer.
Do I have to hire a lawyer to write my representations?
No, you are legally permitted to represent yourself and write your own response. However, because a Proposal to Deny is a critical situation, many applicants seek a law firm to ensure their arguments are strong, properly formatted, and directly address the Board’s specific legal concerns.
Will the Board call me in for an in-person hearing?
No. Record suspension applications in Canada are decided entirely on paper. You will not go to court, and you will not have an in-person interview with the Parole Board of Canada. Your written representations are your only chance to speak to the Board.
Can I ask for an extension on the 90-day deadline?
In extremely rare circumstances, such as severe medical emergencies, you may request an extension. You must contact the PBC in writing well before the deadline expires, provide proof of your emergency, and explain why you need more time. Extensions are not guaranteed.
Leave a Reply