Refusing a breath test in Alberta is generally treated as harshly as a severe impaired driving offence. Under the Criminal Code and the IRS program, a “Refusal to Provide a Sample” results in an immediate 90-day licence suspension, a 30-day vehicle impoundment, and minimum fines starting at $2,000 CAD. You have 7 days to appeal.
A common misconception among drivers is that if you refuse to blow into a roadside screening device, the police will have no evidence against you and will be forced to let you go. This is a dangerous myth. Under Canadian law, specifically the Mandatory Alcohol Screening (MAS) provisions enacted in recent years, police officers do not even need reasonable suspicion of impairment to demand a breath sample during a lawful traffic stop in Edmonton.
If an Edmonton Police Service officer or an RCMP officer asks you to provide a sample and you say no, intentionally fail to blow hard enough, or pretend you cannot perform the test, you will be charged with Refusal to Comply with a Demand. ⚖️ The penalties for refusal are often more severe than if you had simply blown over 0.08. Navigating a refusal charge requires immediate legal intervention from a skilled criminal defence lawyer.
Step-by-Step Process in Edmonton
When you refuse a demand for a breath or bodily fluid sample, the legal consequences trigger immediately on the side of the road. Here is what generally happens and how the legal process unfolds.
Step 1: The Demand and The Refusal
The officer will read you a formal legal demand to provide a breath sample into an Approved Screening Device (ASD). If you refuse, they will typically warn you about the legal consequences of refusing. If you still refuse, or if you provide “fake” blows (not exhaling strongly enough), the officer will record a refusal.
Step 2: Issuance of an IRS Fail (Refusal)
In Alberta, the immediate consequence of a refusal is an IRS Fail. You will be handed a Notice of Administrative Penalty right on the spot. Your licence will be immediately seized and suspended for an absolute period of 90 days, and your vehicle will be towed to an Edmonton impound lot for 30 days.
Step 3: Potential Criminal Charges
While Alberta often uses the administrative IRS system for first-time offenders, police retain the absolute discretion to charge you criminally under the Criminal Code of Canada. If they proceed criminally (usually via summary conviction, or as an indictable offence if there was an accident), you will be given a Promise to Appear in court at the Alberta Court of Justice in downtown Edmonton.
Step 4: Challenging the Refusal via SafeRoads
Whether you face criminal charges or just the provincial penalty, your first line of defence is to appeal the IRS suspension. You must hire a lawyer to file a dispute through the SafeRoads Alberta portal strictly within 7 days. Your lawyer will argue whether the original traffic stop was lawful or if you had a genuine, documented medical excuse for failing to provide a breath volume.
How Much Does it Cost in Edmonton?
A refusal charge is exceptionally expensive. Because the law seeks to discourage people from refusing tests, the fines are higher than standard impaired driving fines:
- Provincial/Criminal Fine: A first-time refusal carries a mandatory minimum fine of $2,000 CAD (compared to $1,000 for a standard first-time blow over 0.08).
- Impound Fees: A 30-day vehicle impoundment will cost approximately $1,200 to $1,500 CAD to retrieve your car.
- Ignition Interlock: After your 90-day absolute suspension, you must install an interlock device for 12 months. The installation and monthly fees total roughly $1,350 CAD for the year.
- Lawyer Fees: Depending on whether you are fighting just the SafeRoads penalty or defending a full criminal trial, legal fees generally range from $3,000 to $10,000+ CAD.
| Offence | Minimum Fine | Licence Suspension Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Blowing over 0.08 (1st Offence) | $1,000 CAD | 90 days absolute + 12 months interlock |
| Refusal to Blow (1st Offence) | $2,000 CAD | 90 days absolute + 12 months interlock |
How Long Does the Process Take?
The immediate driving ban lasts for 15 months (90 days absolute plus a 12-month interlock requirement). If you are appealing via SafeRoads, you will get a decision within 30 days. However, if the Edmonton Police also charged you under the Criminal Code, your criminal court proceedings can take anywhere from 8 to 18 months to reach a trial or resolution.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I refuse the roadside test until my lawyer arrives?
No. Under Canadian law, you do not have the right to consult a lawyer before providing a breath sample into a roadside Approved Screening Device. You must blow immediately. You only have the right to counsel if you are arrested and taken to the station for the formal evidentiary breath test.
What if I have asthma and physically could not blow hard enough?
A genuine medical condition, such as severe asthma or reduced lung capacity, can be a legal defence (a “reasonable excuse”). However, you must provide clear, specialized medical documentation from a doctor to the SafeRoads adjudicator or the court proving that your condition prevented you from completing the test.
Can I demand a blood test instead of a breath test?
No. You do not have the legal right to choose the testing method. If an officer makes a lawful demand for a breath sample, you must provide a breath sample. Refusing and asking for a blood test will still result in a Refusal charge.
Does a refusal charge guarantee a criminal record?
If the police issue an IRS Fail and do not forward the file for federal Criminal Code prosecution, you will not receive a criminal record. However, you will face severe provincial penalties and it will be visible on your provincial driving abstract.
Leave a Reply