Under Canadian employment law, your employer must act honestly and reasonably when executing the terms of your employment contract. Based on the Supreme Court’s Bhasin principle, if an Ontario employer lies or misleads you about crucial matters like bonuses or termination, you may be entitled to aggravated damages in court.
Understanding Good Faith in Ontario Workplaces
When you sign an employment contract, you expect your new boss to keep their promises. For decades, the law treated employment agreements strictly by their written terms. However, whether you work in Toronto, Ottawa, or Kitchener, the legal landscape shifted dramatically to protect workers from dishonest corporate behaviour.
Thanks to a landmark Supreme Court of Canada decision (Bhasin v. Hrynew), there is now an “organizing principle of good faith” woven into every contract. 📍 This means that an employer cannot actively deceive you, lie about the financial health of the company to deny you a bonus, or mislead you about the reasons for your termination. While they do not have to put your interests ahead of their own business goals, they are legally required to perform the contract honestly.
Step-by-Step Guide to Addressing Bad Faith
Proving that an employer acted with malicious intent or dishonesty requires solid evidence and a strategic legal approach. Most applicants in this province rely on a skilled employment law firm to build their case.
Step 1: Identifying Dishonest Conduct
Not every unfair business decision is legally “bad faith.” You must identify active deception. For example, if your employer promises you a lucrative promotion to prevent you from accepting a job with a competitor, knowing full well that they plan to fire you the following month, this is a clear breach of honest performance.
Step 2: Securing Your Documentation
Verbal promises are notoriously difficult to prove in the Superior Court of Justice. You must gather written evidence. 📝 Save all emails, performance reviews, and text messages where the employer makes specific claims about your compensation, job security, or the company’s operational plans before those messages disappear.
Step 3: Reviewing the Employment Agreement
Your lawyer will need to carefully review your original contract. The duty of good faith applies to how the terms of that specific contract are carried out. If your contract states that a bonus is “discretionary,” the employer cannot exercise that discretion in a completely arbitrary, vindictive, or dishonest manner to intentionally deprive you of your earnings.
Step 4: Pursuing Bad Faith Damages
If you are terminated and your employer lies to you or the public about the reason (for instance, falsely claiming you committed fraud), you can seek additional compensation. 💰 These are known as aggravated or moral damages, and they are awarded on top of your standard termination pay and severance packages to compensate you for the mental distress caused by their dishonesty.
Step 5: Filing a Civil Claim
Breaches of good faith are generally not handled by the Ministry of Labour. Instead, your law firm will draft a Statement of Claim to file in civil court. This initiates a formal lawsuit against the corporation for wrongful dismissal and bad faith conduct, forcing them to defend their dishonest actions before a judge.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Litigating a bad faith claim involves private legal fees, as it falls under common law rather than basic statutory rights. Here are estimated costs in CAD:
| Employment Lawyer Initial Consultation | $300 – $500 |
| Demand Letter for Severance & Damages | $1,000 – $2,500 |
| Filing a Civil Lawsuit (Superior Court) | $220 – $400 (Filing fees) |
| Full Civil Litigation (If going to trial) | $15,000 – $40,000+ |
- Contingency Agreements: Many employment lawyers in Ontario will take a wrongful dismissal case on a contingency basis, meaning they only take a percentage (usually 25% to 35%) of the final settlement you receive.
- Cost Awards: If a judge finds that your employer acted in extreme bad faith during the litigation itself, they may order the employer to pay almost all of your legal fees.
How Long Does the Process Take?
In Ontario, you generally have exactly two years from the date of the breach or termination to file a civil lawsuit. 📅 Negotiating a settlement through a demand letter often takes 2 to 4 months. If the employer refuses to offer fair compensation for their dishonest conduct and the matter proceeds to a full trial, the process can drag on for 18 to 24 months due to court backlogs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is bad faith the same as constructive dismissal?
Not exactly. Constructive dismissal happens when an employer fundamentally changes your job duties or slashes your pay without your consent. Bad faith refers specifically to the employer lying or acting maliciously. However, the two often happen at the same time.
Can an employer lie about why I am being fired?
In a standard “without cause” termination, an employer does not have to give a reason. However, if they choose to give a reason, it must not be a deliberate lie meant to harm your reputation or mislead you about your legal rights to severance.
Does this duty apply to independent contractors?
Yes. The organizing principle of good faith and the duty of honest performance established by the Supreme Court of Canada applies to all commercial contracts, which absolutely includes independent contractor and freelance agreements.
Can I sue if they hid financial problems during my interview?
If an employer actively lied about the company’s financial stability to induce you to quit a secure job and join them, and then they go bankrupt two months later, you may have a strong claim for negligent misrepresentation or bad faith.
Leave a Reply